How does Hughes play with expectations in this story?
Readers expect Mrs. Jones to punish Roger or call the police, but instead she shows kindness. This surprise shifts the story from crime to compassion.-
What is the theme of the story, and how does the author use characterization to construct and develop this theme?
The theme is the power of trust and kindness. Mrs. Jones is strict but caring, while Roger changes from a thief into a respectful boy. Their growth shows how compassion can transform people. -
How does Mrs. Luella Bates Washington Jones illustrate her belief in the importance of dignity in the story? What deeper comment might Hughes be making?
She treats Roger with respect—feeding him, trusting him, and giving him money. Hughes suggests that dignity and empathy can teach better than punishment.