For Learning Debate on the Monarchy June 10

Due: Tuesday, 11 June 2024, 1:00 PM
Post replies: 2 Make forum posts: 1

For Learning Debate on the Monarchy June 10

Number of replies: 5

Review the resource on Canada and the British Monarchy. Then answer these questions:

1. What do you think of the connection between Canada and the British Monarchy?  Think about the past and present connection.

2. Do you think it is good for both countries? Why or why not? 

3. In one sense the connection is traditional. Do you think that traditional connections are good? Why or why not? 

**75 words; Answer below in Moodle; Respond to 2 other classmates' postings.


In reply to First post

Re: For Learning Debate on the Monarchy June 10

by Jiaheng (Andrew) Li -
The connection between Canada and the British Monarchy has evolved from colonial rule to a modern constitutional relationship, where the monarchy's role is largely ceremonial, symbolizing historical ties and shared traditions while Canada functions as a fully sovereign and independent nation.

The traditional connection between Canada and the British Monarchy benefits both countries by fostering diplomatic and cultural ties while symbolizing shared history.

Traditional connections can be good as they provide a sense of continuity, identity, and shared history, fostering national unity and stability; however, they should be balanced with adaptability to contemporary values and needs to remain relevant and inclusive.
In reply to First post

Re: For Learning Debate on the Monarchy June 10

by Qichun (Pierce) Zhang -
1. Canada has a very strong connection with the British monarchy 2. I don't think it's very good for Canada because many Canadians think the monarchy is outdated 3. I think this kind of tradition is unnecessary and we should follow the trend of history and seek a new political way
In reply to First post

Re: For Learning Debate on the Monarchy June 10

by Shaohui (Bill) Zhang -
I think the monarchies of the two countries have something in common, symbolizing the consistency of history and tradition. I think this is good for the two countries. The traditional connection is good because it can promote the unity and stability of the country.
In reply to First post

Re: For Learning Debate on the Monarchy June 10

by Yuhan (Yoly) Fu -
The Queen has a unique relationship with Canada, entirely separate from her role as Queen of the United Kingdom or any of her other realms. As in all her realms, The Queen of Canada is a constitutional monarch, acting entirely on the advice of Canadian Government ministers.In Canada, the Canadian ecology is very good, while in the United Kingdom, the United Kingdom is a developed relatively fast country.Canada was a British colony a long time ago, and some of Canada's traditions are similar to those of Britain.
In reply to First post

Re: For Learning Debate on the Monarchy June 10

by Xinling (Poca) Wang -
1.Because Canada was a British colony, the British monarchy played a key role in the establishment of Canada.
2.I think this is good because it has stability for a country and the system has been in place for a long time so a sudden change would make democracy hard to accept.
3.I think it is good for the continuation of traditional culture because it is kind of a historical best effort.