Extra 1.1: DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT: User Experience Comparison

DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT: User Experience Comparison

DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT: User Experience Comparison

by Shuai (Martin) Jiang -
Number of replies: 1

Chat gpt answer:1. Response Accuracy & Reliability

DeepSeek: Gives accurate answers, especially for clear factual questions, but might struggle with more complex or open-ended questions.

ChatGPT: Provides accurate and reliable answers but sometimes lacks detail or might not be as precise with very specific questions.

Test Example:


Question: "Who was the first person to walk on the moon, and when did it happen?"

DeepSeek: Gives a correct, precise answer.

ChatGPT: Also provides the right answer: “Neil Armstrong, July 20, 1969.”

2. Creativity & Writing Style

DeepSeek: Focuses more on facts and may not be as creative in writing tasks.

ChatGPT: Very creative and can write interesting and fun stories with detailed characters and ideas.

Test Example:


Question: "Write a short, engaging story about a futuristic AI assistant."

DeepSeek: Likely gives a more basic answer with fewer details.

ChatGPT: Creates a more imaginative and detailed story.

3. Speed & Performance

DeepSeek: Works well with simple, factual questions but may take longer with more complicated ones.

ChatGPT: Fast at responding and handles both short and long questions well, though it may slow down with very long ones.

Test Example:


Question: "What is the compound interest on $5,000 at an annual rate of 5% over 10 years?"

DeepSeek: Quickly gives the correct calculation.

ChatGPT: Gives the correct answer, along with a quick explanation of how it was calculated.

4. Context Retention

DeepSeek: Might forget what was said earlier in the conversation, making it harder to follow up with related questions.

ChatGPT: Remembers what you talked about, making it easier to have a smooth, back-and-forth conversation.

Test Example:


Follow-up Question: "What if the interest rate was 6% instead of 5%?"

DeepSeek: May need to be reminded of the previous scenario.

ChatGPT: Remembers the earlier question and answers it based on the new details.

5. User Interface & Experience

DeepSeek: Might feel less easy to use and more rigid.

ChatGPT: Simple and easy to use with a friendly design.

Test Experience:


DeepSeek: Could be harder to navigate or less flexible.

ChatGPT: Easy to use and adapts well to your needs.

Conclusion:

DeepSeek is good for answering factual questions, but may not be as creative or flexible.

ChatGPT is better for creative tasks, keeping track of conversations, and offering a more pleasant user experience.

in my personal mind i think deepseek is beter than gpt since it have more details.

deepseek answer:

In reply to Shuai (Martin) Jiang

Re: DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT: User Experience Comparison

by Paul Pu -
Hello Martin,

Well done. Try to reply to your peers after they post.